For the Media

It seems like nearly every delegate at the Republican Convention last week, following Sarah Palin's introduction to the world, described her leading qualification as being "a beautiful lady" or some derivative thereof. Putting aside the matter of whether there should be concern that the politically sophisticated attendees at the convention offer this as a qualification for office, it is interesting to note how smitten they seemed to be by her. Is she really all that?

I have a feeling that I will end up mentioning often in this blog that, as political scientists, we don't have that much scientific to say regarding this election. That is not to say we don't try, but just that elections are extremely complex phenomenon, and they are hard to measure scientifically.However, I do have something scientific to say about Sarah Palin's appearance.

There is a buzz around about whether Palin's looks will help her move from Juneau to Washington. An honest political scientist will tell you that they do not know the answer to that question. However, I can begin to have some informed speculation because I have actually quantified Palin's looks - as I have those of Joe Biden, Mitt Romney, and hundreds of other politicians. The Grand Old Delegates might be disappointed to learn that their candidate's appearance is only 0.75. Based on all the chatter about her on websites, such as http://vpilf.com, and the schoolyard talk of some of my Right-minded friends, you might think her supporters are ready to declare her a 10, the fact that my scale only goes to 1.06, not withstanding.

However, despite the seemingly unimpressive score of 0.75, her new throngs of admirers would probably be happy to know (and have their opinion confirmed) that she is far above the average politician, in fact she is firmly in the top 5% of politicians when it comes to looks.

Let me explain how I can claim to know all of this.

My colleagues, Matthew Atkinson, Seth Hill, and I undertook a survey that quantified the "facial competence" of hundreds of candidates for Congress and governor's mansions, between 1990 and 2006. This was following on the work of the psychologist Alexander Todorov and his colleagues at Princeton. They showed undergraduate students photographs of the faces of competing candidates and asked them to pick the more "competent." In the journal Science, they demonstrated that the difference between the ratings of which candidate was more competent, correlated, that is matched up, with the difference in actual vote share between the two candidates. The more competent looking candidate won the actual election almost 70% of the time. What's more, they only flashed these photographs for a very short time, about 1 second. So, the judgements that correlated with election outcomes were actually snap-judgements, not reasoned opinions.

Todorov and his colleagues did not take a position on whether their research means that voters are making decisions about for whom to vote based on who is better looking. It is an intriguing question though, that raises some others. Do people actually even know what candidates for relatively obscure offices, like the United States House of Representatives, look like? If they do, what type of person would actually have their vote changed by this? Would a Republican really vote for a Democrat because the Republican candidate isn't pretty enough?

In many ways, their finding was compelling and curious: there is well-supported political science evidence that the more attention a person pays to an election, the more likely they are to be a firm believer in one side or the other. So, would a person that pays enough attention that they know what a candidate looks like, and is a firm believer in, say, the GOP, really vote for a Democrat because that Democrat was just so much better looking?

Questions like these led us to undertake a similar study. However, we created a scale that allows a comparison of all candidates, Palin to Biden for example, and not just those candidates that actually ran against each other. To do this, we sat hundreds of UCLA students in front of computer screens and flashed photos of the candidates at them. Instead of just flashing the pairs of candidates that actually ran against each other, we randomly matched candidates, and asked the students to choose which looked more competent. This allowed us to create a scale with a score for the face of every candidate. Seth has an example of the survey on his webpage at http://sjhill.bol.ucla.edu/faces/ The numbers don't mean anything in an absolute sense. The scale is arbitrary, but the numbers have a relative meaning. So, if you like Palin, don't get too upset about her seemingly low score. I'll explain how she stacks up against her competitors shortly.

For those of you that like sports, this method of scaling is somewhat similar to how those computer rankings are made for college football. Those rankings allow for two teams that have not played each other to still be compared because the computer keeps track of how they did against common opponents or a team that one team played that played a team that the other team played. Or a team that one played that played a team that played a team that the other played, etc. If there are enough games, these rankings can give a fairly accurate idea of how two teams compare, even though they never actually played each other. Now, for those of you saying that those darn rankings keep your team out of their bowl game every year!, you might be right because in college football, there are not many games, and the accuracy is dependent on the number of games that occur. In our study, each face engaged in hundreds of "games" against other faces -- so we are fairly confident about the accuracy of our ratings. Can we separate Palin from Elizabeth Dole who has a score of 0.755 (Palin is actually 0.752)? Not very well (the typical score has a standard error of about 0.11). But we can be almost certain that Palin is far better looking than her opponent Biden. He scored a relatively measly 0.38 (although Biden is still doing better than the mean score of 0.22).

Now, before you express your disgust at having read this far just to have somebody tell you the shocking news that Sarah Palin has a better face than Joe Biden, there is some less obvious information out there. How does Palin compare to other names that were floated for the GOP Vice Presidential nomination? As far as faces go, Palin was a far better choice than the often mentioned Minnesota Governor Tim Pawlenty (-0.14). However, she can't quite stack up with the even more oft mentioned, and acclaimed as handsome, Mitt Romney (0.93). Of course, there was some quiet chatter about John McCain choosing Texas Senator Kay Baily Hutchison, presumably to court the female vote, as some claim is the reason he chose Palin. When it comes to faces, Palin was the better choice, as Hutchison only came in at 0.56.

How does Palin do against the rejected Democratic VP possibilities? Quite well against Governors Tim Kaine of Virginia (0.11) and Kathleen Sebelius of Indiana (0.14). Even better against Senator Chris Dodd of Connecticut (0.05). However, had Barack Obama chosen Evan Bayh of Indiana, he might have stood a chance, facially, against Palin, with a score of 0.63.

In fact, we found across all candidates, for all offices, Republicans, on average, have more competent faces than Democrats. Take that for what you well, but incumbents tend to have more competent faces and Republicans were in the majority for most of the years covered in our survey.

Now you say, what about the politicians we really want to hear about? McCain? Obama? Hillary Clinton? I have not avoided mentioning them for the purposes of suspense. I have no scores for them. In doing the ratings, we removed the photos of candidates that the students were likely to recognize. The idea is to have the students make decisions based on appearance alone, not other opinions they might have about the person. Romney stayed in the sample because in spring 2007, when we conducted the survey, Romney was a nobody - at least to college students - the overwhelming majority of whom could not even identify a photo of their own, long serving Member of Congress, Henry Waxman. Romney, however, was not as much of a nobody as Sarah Palin, even though one of my colleagues now recalls being struck by her beauty when we were preparing the photos for the survey. It seems then, that in getting her face rated, the half-term Governor from Alaska, benefited from her obscurity. The same obscurity that some have argued helped her in becoming a finalist for the position of "heartbeat away" from the most powerful post in the world.

Of course, I did start by giving the "hottest VP candidate ever" only a 0.75. To avoid any accusations of bias on my blog, I should repeat that she is in the top 5% of politicians we rated. The 95th percentile ain't bad. I don't know if it will satisfy her most ardent supporters, but this means we can give her a 9.5 out of 10 (scientifically speaking).

Permalink

On-topic comments that add to the discussion are welcome. Please respect each other and the forum by using your real name and a civil tone. Spam and comments judged by UCLA to be libelous, offensive or abusive may be deleted without notice

Comments

Tonya Elliott says:

A great issue to blog about. Great info. Thanks. <a href="http://www.onlyhotfitnessmodels.com/tonya-elliott/">Tonya Elliott</a>

messigreat29 says:

I have been reading your post regularly. They are highly informative and helpful. http://www.teethwhiteninginstructions.com

Colon Cleanse says:

Thanks for the information, it was really useful. I was looking for it and I'll be waiting for your next post. http://www.buzzle.com/articles/netflix-review-netflix-dvd-rentals-and-online-steaming-of-latest-movies.html http://www.articlesbase.com/men%27s-health-articles/extenze-truth-about-extenze-pills-1638605.html http://www.goarticles.com/cgi-bin/showa.cgi?C=1822947 http://www.goarticles.com/cgi-bin/showa.cgi?C=2423167 http://www.coloncleanseinformation.com/

Senandung says:

http://www.beauty.ajib.org/ http://www.beauty.ajib.org/seo/optimasi-on-page.html http://www.beauty.ajib.org/about http://www.beauty.ajib.org/sitemap

Bob Mu says:

<a href="http://www.besthomehumidifier.com" rel="follow">ultrasonic humidifier</a> ultrasonic humidifier <a href="http://topratedwashingmachines.blogspot.com" rel="follow">cheap washing machines</a> cheap washing machines <a href="http://homesteampress.blogspot.com/" rel="follow">singer steam press</a> singer steam press <a href="http://www.kai-lo.com" rel="follow">professional seo services</a> professional seo services <a href="http://makemoneyonline18.blogspot.com" rel="follow">easy ways to make money online</a> easy ways to make money online <a rel="follow" href="http://cheaplaptopbatteriesdeal.blogspot.com">toshiba laptop battery</a> toshiba laptop battery <a rel="follow" href="http://cheapwirelessmouse.blogspot.com">wireless mouse for laptop</a> wireless mouse for laptop <a rel="follow" href="http://www.ihatemyexsomuch.com">how to get your ex back</a> how to get your ex back <a rel="follow" href="http://coldairintakesystems.blogspot.com/">k&n cold air intake</a> k&n cold air intake <a rel="follow" href="http://cheappaydayloantoday.blogspot.com/">cheap payday loan</a> cheap payday loan <a rel="follow" href="http://cheappaydayloantoday.blogspot.com/2010/02/payday-loan-information.html">payday loan information</a> payday loan information <a rel="follow" href="http://coldairintakesystems.blogspot.com/2010/02/cold-air-intake-kits.html">cold air intake kits</a> cold air intake kits

Ledy XAXa says:

Mc Cain made a huge mistake choosing Palin for his campaign. <a href="http://www.solarpowergenerators.ca">Solar Power Generators</a> <a href="http://www.solarpowergenerators.ca"/>wind power generator</a> <a herf="http://bestvideogamessite.info/">video games</a>

jenny josh says:

thanks for this informative blog on Republican Convention.http://www.ezinearticles.com/?Stretch-Marks---What-is-the-Best-Way-to-Get-Rid-of-Stretch-Marks?&id=2666384

GoMe says:

I am so pleased that he is being recognised for his brilliance in this way. You deserve it all my friend.Thanks for everything. <a rel="dofollow" href="http://www.gomecomputer.com/astagacom-lifestyle-on-the-net">Astaga.com lifestyle on the net</a> <a rel="dofollow" href="http://www.gomecomputer.com/festival-museum-nusantara">Festival Museum Nusantara</a> | <a rel="dofollow" href="http://www.gomecomputer.com/nowgooglecom-adalah-multiple-search-engine-popular">nowGoo gle.com Adalah Multiple Search Engine Popular</a>

melSSinde says:

direction the country <a href="http://liselilolitakizlaretekalti.blogspot.com" title="Liseli Kizlar Etekalti Frikikleri,Am Firikik,18lik Rus Kiz Resimleri,Japon Çitirlar">liseli kizlar</a>-<a href="http://seksimagazin.blogspot.com" title="ünlüler,sicak,seksi kizlar,resimleri,resimi,mankenler,sicak videolar">sexsi</a>-<a href="http://guzellolitakizlar.blogspot.com" title="kiz resimleri,çiplak lolita resimleri,am fotolari,bakire,etekalti frikik,gögüs,meme">firikik</a>-<a href="http://yesilcamerotikporno.blogspot.com" title="yesilcam pornosu,yerli porno izle,yeşilçam sikiş,türk pornosu,yesilcam erotik film">yesilcam pornosu</a>-<a href="http://sikispornosu-izle.blogspot.com" title="sikiş,seks videosu,sikis videolari,sexs,anal sikis izle,türk pornosu">anal sikis</a>- <a href="http://bizevdeyiz-tv.blogspot.com/" title="bizevdeyiz,sikis izle,porno izle,canli kizlar,canli şov seyret,seks videosu">canli sikis</a>--<a href="http://konulupornofilmizle.blogspot.com" title="18lik porno,lolita pornosu,konulu porno film,porno,uzun pornolar izle,pornosu">uzun pornolar</a>----<a href="http://pornofilmfulindir.blogspot.com" title="full porno indir-pornosunu indir-pornolari-bedava-full-yukle-download-free">full porno indir</a> wants to turn, particularly <font size="4">-<a href="http://www.enguncel.org" title="film izle,indirmeden izle,bedava film izle,online izle,seyret,erotik film izle">indirmeden izle</a>-<a href="http://www.nowindir.com" title="full program,inndir,tam indir,free indir,son sürüm,inndir,full film indir">inndir</a>-<a href="http://online-muzik-dinle-video.blogspot.com" title="online şarki dinle,dinle,mp3 dinleme,müzik dinle,bedava albüm indir">şarkisini dinle</a>-<a href="http://justintv-canlizle.blogspot.com" title="justintv izle,turks tv seyret,canli justintv den izle,maçini online izle">justin tv</a>-<a href="http://www.fulindir.tk" title="full indir,full program indir,serial,crack,full film,full oyun yükle,ful yükle">yükle</a>-<a href="http://pornofilmfulindir.blogspot.com" title="full porno indir-pornosunu indir-pornolari-bedava-full-yukle-download-free">full porno indir</a>-----<a href="http://akillitv.turkblog.com" title="18lik Porno izle-Sikiş Videolari-Lezbiyen Pornolari-Bedava Porno izle">18lik porno</a>--<a href="http://canlisikistv.turkblog.com" title="canli sikis tv-canlipornokanallari-adult tv izle-seks tv seyret-canli porno-sikiş kanallari-online porno">canli porno kanallari</a>

allala says:

-<a href="http://www.sadeceonsekiz.com" title="porno izle,sikis,full pornolar,bedava kadin pornosu,konulu pornosu seyret,18lik">18konulu</a>---</font>in times of crisis where deep problems must be solved and fateful decisions made. I think that those of us in the universities who spend their lives studying the problems and the institutions that must be used to reach solution should try to <a href="http://liseli.vox.com/library/post/hindistan-pornosu-izle.html">hint pornosu</a>contribute some more substance to the national discussion. When we chose George HW Bush it was done too much about the silly hat that Michael Dukakis wore when he climbed into the tank and a particular black prisoner that one of his policies released from <a href="http://recepivedik3sinemacekimi.blogcu.com/">recepivedik3sinemacekimi</a>--<a href="http://kutsaldamacana2idman.blogcu.com/">kutsaldamacana2idman</a> <a href='http://twitter.com/delikarar'>-</a> <a href='http://xvideos-xx.blogspot.com/'>xvideos</a>--<a href='http://vidyovidio.wordpress.com/'>vidyo</a>---"><a href='http://gunlukfilmizle.blogcu.com/'>günlükfilm</a>---<a href='http://nowindir.wordpress.com/'>tikla indir</a>prison than about education reform, or environment, or anything el

Reverse Phone Lookup says:

Few good quality links to trace the person making unwanted calls:http://www.goarticles.com/cgi-bin/showa.cgi?C=2392259 http://www.articlesbase.com/communication-articles/facts-on-free-reverse-phone-lookup-you-must-know-1598084.html http://www.buzzle.com/articles/reverse-phone-look-up-how-to-trace-any-phone-number-with-reverse-cell-phone-look-up-services.html

your business ads says:

<a href="http://chidoguey.com/">chidoguey.com</a> <li><a href="http://newpokerevents.com/">Apostar online</a></li> <li><a href="http://rutina.com.mx">Ejercicios para todo el puerco</a></li> <li><a href="http://jpeg.com.mx">FOTOS y Más</a></li> <li><a href="http://0o.com.mx">Harto Tech</a></li> <li><a href="http://mp3descargas.com.mx">Mucha música</a></li> <li><a href="http://p2.com.mx" rel="contact" title="Blog de actualidad y análisis" target="_blank">Muchos Pedos</a></li> <li><a href="http://informando.com.mx">Noticias y más!</a></li> <li><a href="http://laletra.com.mx">Todas las letras para cantar.</a></li> <li><a href="http://cochera.com.mx">Todo para mi coche</a></li> <li><a href="http://videoblogs.com.mx">Todos los videos</a></li> <li><a href="http://changarro.com.mx">Triunfa en los negocios</a></li> <li><a href="http://www.yourbusinessads.com/" title="The Best Articles And The Hottest Tips" target="_blank">Your Bussines Ads</a> <a href="http://www.yourbusinessads.com/" title="The Best Articles And The Hottest Tips" target="_blank">your business ads</a>

James Taylor says:

<a href="http://www.infinitylogodesign.com/">Logo Design</a>

messigreat29 says:

Sarah Palin has been in news from a very long time for one reason or the other <a href="http://www.teethwhiteninginstructions.com">Teeth Whitening</a> <a href="http://ezinearticles.com/?Teeth-Whitening---Which-is-the-Best-Teeth-Whitening-Product?&id=2660517">Teeth Whitening</a>

Air Ambulance says:

Your post has alot of value. I m waiting for your next post. http://www.statair.com

Dave says:

That's a really well thought out article. Thanks. http://www.acaiberryfrance.fr/

paula says:

Hey this is really nice information. I was looking for something similar like this. Thanks for this useful information.http://www.articlesbase.com/supplements-and-vitamins-articles/acai-berry-weight-loss-try-acai-berry-for-free-1798369.html http://www.goarticles.com/cgi-bin/showa.cgi?C=2459543

Air Ambulance says:

I m really impressed .I m waiting for your next post.

Andini says:

http://www.pakarseo.net/kontes-seo/posisi-nowgoogle-com-yang-mengejutkan.html http://www.pakarseo.net/kontes-seo/rahasia-kontes-nowgoogle-com.html http://tutorial-seo-blogger.blogspot.com/2010/02/optimasi-kontes-astagacom.html http://ilmu-belajar-komputer.blogspot.com/2010/01/nowgooglecom.html http://www.sahabatsejati.com/blogger/nowgoogle-com-adalah-multiple-search-engine-popular.html

Rester says:

RSS Alerts

Facebook Twitter Youtube

About

Election analysis and personal commentary by UCLA scholars, unfiltered.

News release

Contact UCLA Newsroom

RSS Feed

For the Media

Current Issues

Useful Links

Palin a 9.5, scientifically speaking

Comments

Tonya Elliott says:

messigreat29 says:

Colon Cleanse says:

Senandung says:

Bob Mu says:

Ledy XAXa says:

jenny josh says:

GoMe says:

melSSinde says:

allala says:

Reverse Phone Lookup says:

your business ads says:

James Taylor says:

messigreat29 says:

Air Ambulance says:

Dave says:

paula says:

Air Ambulance says:

Andini says:

Rester says:

Tool Tip

Tool Tip

About

Our Bloggers

Archive